×
ECR

ECR Co-Chair uncovers double standards of the majority Groups in the EP around rule of law in Europe

26 March 2021

ECR Co-Chair uncovers double standards of the majority Groups in the EP around rule of law in Europe

Co-Chairman of the European Conservatives and Reformists Group in the European Parliament, Prof Ryszard Legutko, has rebutted claims that the Polish Supreme Court failed to uphold the rule of law principle by departing from the Court of Justice of the European Union's (CJEU) interim measure.

Reacting to a letter, co-signed by European Parliament majority group leaders addressed to European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and published on the news media website Politico Europe, Co-Chairman Prof Legutko stated:

“First and foremost, it should be pointed out that it is not true that the Disciplinary Chamber of the Polish Supreme Court did not follow the Court of Justice of the European Union’s (CJEU) interim measure. The Commission, in case C-791/19 conducted before the CJEU, is currently interrogating the Disciplinary Chamber of the Polish Supreme Court on whether adjudicating in disciplinary cases against judges is within its field of competence. Upon request of the Commission, the CJEU decided on the application ofthe interim measure of 8 April, 2020, in which it ordered Poland to suspend the activities of the Disciplinary Chamber to the extent that it conducts disciplinary proceedings in cases relating to judges.

“It must be underlined that the Disciplinary Chamber, since its establishment in 2017, adjudicates also in other, non-disciplinary cases. This is why it was lawfully possible and in accordance with the interim measure for the Disciplinary Chamber to waive the immunity of Judge Igor Tuleya on 18 November 2020; as cases concerning waiving the immunity are not disciplinary proceedings and are not covered by the interim measure. Based on these facts, it is not true that the Disciplinary Chamber is operating illegally. This interpretation was also indirectly backed by the Commission by broadening the scope of the infringement proceedings concerning the Disciplinary Chamber to include waiver of immunity cases as well. Earlier claims did not take this aspect into account.

“Both Judge Tuleya and the other three judges against whom applications for waivers of immunity were made are to be charged with criminal offenses. In every Member State, wherever judges enjoy immunity, there must be a way to waive it. Without such a possibility, judges would be above the law and would not be criminally liable for any crimes committed. It should also be taken into account that after judges’ immunity has been waived, their criminal cases will be conducted before the relevant criminal courts. They will not be tried in disciplinary proceedings by the Disciplinary Chamber of the Supreme Court.

“The letter of the leaders of the majority groups of the European Parliament once again shows double standards: The standard procedure for the waiver of judges’ immunity, conducted in every Member State where judges have immunity to be able to bring criminal charges against these judges, is attacked only in Poland. The very strict adherence to the interim measure is also attacked with completely untrue and extra-legal allegations. Such behaviour only strengthens Poland and Poles in the conviction that their actions are right.“

SHARE

ECR

OUR TWEETS

ECR Group

yesterday

The aim of the Conference on the #FutureOfEurope is for Brussels to seize competences in the fields of family, cult… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

yesterday

We don’t want to impose a single way of thinking. We have to embrace other visions. Our history and our spiritual… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

yesterday

This Conference on the #FutureofEurope must not have a preselected result. It cannot just be a rhetorical bridge f… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

yesterday

"In spite of appearances, #Europe – the whole of Europe – is often not very visible from the European institutions… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

yesterday

From #Brussels or #Strasbourg, you can’t really see the real #Europe – the social, cultural and economic diversity;… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

yesterday

The inaugural #CoFoE #EPlenary session is commencing! Follow it now below! We'll be standing for: 🛡️ safe, secure… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

2 days ago

"We need to think about what we can do together to orient the development of Latin America in the right direction"… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

3 days ago

"We've banded together, joined forces, united continents... and we're immensely proud of the results" 🗣️ MEP… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

3 days ago

The 1st 🌍 #Eurolat Summit 2021 🌎 is over. 👉 From the renewal of democratic process to stopping narco-financed gove… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

3 days ago

"Latin America and Europe share a truly historic bond." @Santi_ABASCAL #EuroLat





© 2020. All rights reserved. European Conservatives and Reformists Group