Skip to content
Bringing back common sense

European culture, cinema and independent producers deserve strong support, but the proposed AgoraEU programme gives too little weight to the cultural sector while leaving too much scope for EU money to finance political advocacy and ideological priorities, ECR Shadow Rapporteurs Ivaylo Valchev and Alessandro Ciriani said following today’s joint vote in the European Parliament’s Culture and Civil Liberties Committees.

The ECR Group voted against the report and the negotiating mandate. While the final compromise includes stronger support for European cinema, independent producers, lesser-used languages and cultural heritage, the Conservative MEPs believe fundamental problems remain in the way the 2028–2034 programme is structured, governed and funded.

ECR Shadow Rapporteur in the Culture Committee Ivaylo Valchev said:

“Culture cannot be treated as an annoying, uninvited guest in its own programme. We support European culture, cinema and independent producers, but only 21 per cent of this budget is dedicated to culture, while more than 40 per cent goes to strands carrying a much broader political agenda.

“We secured some real improvements for culture: stronger support for European cinema and independent producers, recognition of lesser-used languages and cultural heritage, and a clear emphasis on human creativity. But it is all the more regrettable that these gains are tied to a programme whose wider political direction we cannot support.

“European cultural funding should help artists, filmmakers, producers and cultural institutions create and compete. It should not become a vehicle for priorities that have little to do with culture itself.”

ECR Shadow Rapporteur in the Civil Liberties Committee Alessandro Ciriani raised particular concerns about the use of public money for advocacy and lobbying activities directed at EU institutions.

Ciriani said:

“What we are seeing is that EU money could be used to finance lobbying of the very institutions that distribute it. Public funding requires clear rules, transparency and accountability. This text does not give us sufficient guarantees that this line will be respected.

“Civil society has an important role, but there must be a clear distinction between supporting legitimate activities and using taxpayers’ money to finance political campaigning. European institutions should not fund organisations and then rely on those same organisations to lobby them for particular political outcomes.”

He also criticised the governance of the programme, under which work programmes would be adopted through delegated acts without a programme committee giving Member States a direct role.

“When billions of euros of public money are being distributed, Member States cannot simply be pushed to the sidelines. Decisions about priorities, eligibility and spending need proper democratic scrutiny and political accountability,” Ciriani said.

AgoraEU is intended to bring together the current Creative Europe and Citizens, Equality, Rights and Values programmes under one framework for 2028–2034, covering culture, audiovisual and news media, civil society, fundamental rights and democratic participation. The Commission presented the merger as a way of simplifying EU funding and creating greater flexibility between policy areas.

The ECR Group supports continued European cooperation in culture and media, including measures to strengthen the competitiveness of Europe’s audiovisual sector and independent producers, as well as effective action against violence against women and children. However, it considers that the final AgoraEU compromise fails to provide a sufficiently clear separation between cultural support, civil-society funding and politically driven advocacy.

The joint CULT-LIBE vote was: 64 in favour, 17 against and 2 abstentions.