EU Dublin regulation: reinvention of the wheel would be a recipe for chaos

20 January 2016

EU Dublin regulation: reinvention of the wheel would be a recipe for chaos

Proposals to reform the EU’s Dublin Regulation should focus on helping to better implement rules in place, not to reinvent the wheel, Timothy Kirkhope MEP, said today as he sent a list of proposals for Dublin reform to the European Commission.

The European Conservatives and Reformists’ Home Affairs spokesman put forward the proposals to feed into the reform that is expected in March.

In the proposals he recommends:

– That the Dublin Regulation should retain the same basic principles but should learn from the previous mistakes of the EU emergency relocation system, which has not been successful.

– At its core, Dublin should still see asylum decisions remain with the country of entry into the EU, and the Dublin Regulation should make clear who is responsible for processing of an application to avoid states pushing migrants around the continent.

– However, should Dublin returns to a particular EU state be suspended, other states should be able to return people to the nearest functioning ‘hotspot’ to their original point of entry. This will discourage further movement and states encouraging asylum seekers and migrants to travel onward within the EU.

– The European Commission should ensure that countries are carrying out these returns, and that asylum seekers are given decent conditions, swift fingerprinting and processing upon arrival.

– The Dublin Regulation and any relocation mechanism should be kept as separate instruments, particularly given the lack of success of the temporary relocation mechanism. An emergency relocation mechanism could apply, but countries could have the option participate in the direct resettlement programme of the UNHCR.

– Any EU country that wishes to suspend Dublin returns to them should undergo a European Commission impact assessment. If they suspend returns they should have their Schengen membership suspended or should accept assistance from the EU to protect the border.

– If there is evidence that an asylum seeker or migrant has been in another EU Member State for some time without claiming asylum, the person should be returned to that state for processing, in order to prevent secondary movement or states seeking to push asylum seekers to other EU countries.

Timothy Kirkhope, a former UK Immigration Minister, said:

“To completely reinvent the Dublin regulation in the midst of a crisis is the wrong approach. We need to stick to a method that has been tried and tested, but which countries are failing to enforce effectively.

“The Dublin Regulation can be tweaked to make it more effective, and to prevent countries seeking to nudge refugees and migrants to other countries. Countries need to live up to their responsibilities and the European Commission needs to demand that they implement the rules that they have signed up to. If they cannot play by the rules then other countries should help them to manage the situation and provide extra resources, or they should temporarily be subjected to internal EU border controls.

“I have submitted some of my thoughts to the European Commission on how we can make Dublin effective without tearing up the rule book in the middle of a crisis.”




ECR Party

15 hours ago

On this day 30 years ago: Czechs and Slovaks took to the streets demanding the end of authoritarian communism. To… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

Jan Zahradil

16 hours ago

Bank holiday today in #CzechRepublic. 80 years ago, November 17, 1939: big rally in Prague against Nazi occupation.… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

Jan Zahradil


Last night in #Prague: tribute to Sir @Roger_Scruton for his support of Czechoslovak dissent before 1989. Awarded M… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

Poland in the EU

3 days ago

We hosted today a debate on terrorist content online regulation in partnership with @ZPP_EU. Our keynote speakers… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

3 days ago

ECR will always work for a free market economy and against protectionist policies. MEP @robertszile grilling Transp… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

Bert-Jan Ruissen

3 days ago

Net in het Europarlement de kandidaat-EU-commissaris László Trócsányi voor Nabuurschap en Uitbreiding gevraagd naar… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

4 days ago

Interesting and strong testimony from Andrew Brunson on the importance of #freedomofreligion, hosted by our MEP… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

5 days ago

We wouldn’t have a unified Europe if the people of Central and Eastern Europe had not have fought Communism 30 year… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

Prawo i Sprawiedliwość

6 days ago

101. rocznica odzyskania przez Polskę Niepodległości. #11listopada #ŚwiętoNiepodległości 🇵🇱 pic.twitter.com/napTF7oZvb


6 days ago

Happy #IndependenceDay, Poland! 🇵🇱 The past 101 years were not always easy, some were pretty hard, some were legen… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

© 2018. All rights reserved. European Conservatives and Reformists Group