×
ECR

Legal opinion affirms that the Green Deal reduction trajectory cannot be delegated to the Commission

24 April 2020

Legal opinion affirms that the Green Deal reduction trajectory cannot be delegated to the Commission

ECR Group: Executive Vice President Timmermans should now withdraw his legally flawed proposal.

The European Parliament’s Legal Service has reaffirmed its April 1 non-paper conclusion that the Commission’s attempt to self-delegate power, allowing it to set the trajectory for achieving emission reduction targets under the Green Deal, is an overreach of the Commission’s mandate.

A legal opinion requested by the ECR Group on the draft Climate Law makes clear that the proposed emission reduction trajectory establishes a pathway between two legally binding targets (i.e. 2030 and 2050). Therefore, by definition, it is an integral part of the legislation and cannot be delegated to the Commission in accordance with the Treaties.

It also ascertains that although the trajectory is not itself legally binding, it could nevertheless bring about legal obligations as the criteria for establishing the trajectory require complex political decision-making that takes full account of all economic, environmental, and social concerns.

The ECR Group is confident that the conclusions drawn in this latest legal opinion will finally put an end to the Parliament’s debate on the Commission’s use of “delegated acts” in the Climate Law.

The ECR’s Anna Zalewska MEP, Shadow Rapporteur for the European Climate Law and co-initiator of the assessment, said:

“The legal opinion proves beyond dispute that the Commission is attempting to act beyond its mandate. It is fundamentally important that MEPs, and the citizens who elect them, should not be sidelined in determining the impact of the Commission’s proposal. What we now need is a discussion amongst the Commission, the Parliament, and the Council concerning the EU’s emissions targets and find a realistic way forward without undercutting the Union’s Treaties.”

Alexandr Vondra MEP, ECR Coordinator for the Environment Committee and co-initiator, added:

“Executive Vice President Timmermans should withdraw this legally flawed proposal. The Director-General of the WHO has warned that the worst of COVID-19’s impact is still to come, and the IMF is currently projecting that GDP in the Eurozone will contract by 7.5% in 2020. In this context, the Parliament’s legislative work must focus on the post-pandemic recovery. If Mr. Timmermans is truly an advocate of fact-based evidence, then he should allow for more time to conduct assessments under the 2030 Climate Target Plan. This would better enable the collection of accurate data on the economic impact of this public health crisis, in turn, providing more time to correct the legal elements of this proposal.”

SHARE

ECR

OUR TWEETS

ECR Group

23 minutes ago

ECR MEP @RuzaTomasic's opinion on the Impacts of #EU 🇪🇺 rules on the free movements of workers and services has bee… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

7 hours ago

La Multi Ani, Romania! 🇷🇴 The ECR Group wishes all Romanians a very Happy #GreatUnionDay! #ZiuaMariiUniri pic.twitter.com/qvSTEqgXi4

ECR Group

yesterday

It is with great sadness that we learn of the passing of Remo Sernagiotto, MEP from 2014-2019 and a passionate Euro… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

2 days ago

As December draws close, the ECR Group wishes the Christians of 🇪🇺 and the world a very Happy First Sunday of Adven… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

4 days ago

This week, @EU_Commission Executive Vice-President Margerethe @vestager joined ECR Members, including @Assita_Kankotwitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

4 days ago

In today's @EP_ForeignAff committee meeting, ECR MEPs @AnnaFotyga_PE and @Assita_Kanko engaged with key Russian 🇷🇺… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

4 days ago

ECR MEP @GeertBourgeois speaks up for tightening 🇪🇺 🇺🇸 relations through the #LobsterDeal. Today, the @Europarl_ENtwitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

4 days ago

ECR MEP @Assita_Kanko calls for #EU action after EU citizen and crisis-relief doctor #AhmadRezaJalali is detained b… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

ECR Group

4 days ago

As @europarl votes to adopt the resolution on the so-called #LobsterDeal, 🇪🇺 member states and 🇺🇸 have taken a smal… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

Anna Fotyga - Biuro Poselskie

5 days ago

I Thee Wed... Centennial Anniversary of Poland's Return to the Baltic Sea pscp.tv/w/co5OYzF3QkVB…





© 2020. All rights reserved. European Conservatives and Reformists Group